Study the Record – Most appeals are fact-driven; therefore, a thorough working knowledge of the record is critical.
Know the Correct Standard of Review – This will dictate both what you argue, and how you present it.
Think About Your Presentation – If appellant, decide what you will emphasize (generally, you should present your strongest argument first); if appellee, put yourself in shoes of opponent, and try to anticipate what she will argue.
Outline Your Argument – Obviously, this is easier if you are appellant than if you are appellee, but you should prepare at least a rough outline even if appellee.
Prepare a Brief Opening and Closing – Prepare and memorize a brief opening and closing (three or four sentences each), but do not attempt to memorize a set speech.
Anticipate the Hard Questions – And be prepared to address them.
Check out the Panel – If possible, go and watch some arguments the day before yours; pay particular attention to how the panel interacts with those arguing, and each other.
Get to the Courthouse Early – Allow for unexpected delays, changes in order of arguments, etc.
Dress Professionally – What you wear should not detract from what you have to say.
Communicate Clearly and Concisely – Your task is twofold, to inform and to persuade; you will not succeed at either unless you follow this tip.
Do Not Read Your Argument
Do Not Make a Jury Argument – Appellate courts are in the business of correcting errors of law.
Welcome Questions – These will generally reflect the judges’ concerns, and a good answer may make the difference between winning and losing.
Act Professionally – Treat the lower tribunal, your opponent and the judges as you would like to be treated–with respect.
When You’re Finished, Sit Down – Simply because you’ve been allotted a certain amount of time doesn’t mean you must fill it.
Use Rebuttal Wisely – If appellant, always reserve time for rebuttal (should almost never be more than 3 minutes); use the time to make one or two quick, strong points in response to appellee’s argument; if you have nothing good to say, waive it.
If you’d like to submit an article for The Record, please contact the Editor, Courtney L. Fernald, at firstname.lastname@example.org.
To help with your search, each archived issue of The Record is presented with the Table of Contents, the Author and a brief description of the article. We continue to add archived articles to this website so that they will be searchable and therefore, more accessible.
Court Surety Bond Agency (CSBA) is the nation's leading surety agency specializing in supersedeas bonds. If you have a client needing to stay enforcemen5t of a judgment in Florida, or any other state or federal court, contact Court Surety.